Invalidity of a transaction, fundamentals of law and order, fundamentals of morality, public order, disputed transactions, void transactions, antisocial transactions


The legal problems of the invalidity of a transaction made for a purpose that is obviously contrary to the foundations of law and order or morality have been scientifically and theoretically investigated. The experience of foreign countries on this issue, its genesis and legal concepts were also touched upon. At the same time, special attention is paid to the legal consequences of the invalidity of the transaction, antisocial and controversial transactions, the theoretical aspects of the recognition of the transaction invalid by the court are studied. In addition, in the legislative acts on the invalidity of the transaction in the Europe countries, the relevant norms have been investigated, and the author has expressed his opinion and comments. An attempt has been made to widely publicize the factors recognized as invalid, as well as issues of restitution. In this regard, it should be particularly noted that he tried to comprehensively study the legal aspects of invalidation of the transaction, which indicates the relevance of this topic.



Afanasyev D. V. Violation of public order as a basis for invalidating a transaction in Russian and foreign law // Invalidity in civil law: problems, trends, practice: Collection of articles. - M., 2006. p.79.

Swiss Code of Obligations 1911)//

Zweigert K., Ketz H. Introduction to Comparative Jurisprudence in the field of private law. Vol. 2 Trans. From German - M., 1998. pp.83-84.

Judgment 1 of the Chamber of the Court of Cassation of June 3, 1970 //

N.V. Vaseva Antisocial transactions in Soviet civil law: Dis. Cand. legal entity sciences. - Sverdlovsk, 1978. P. 76.

Commentary to the Civil Code of the Republic of Uzbekistan. Volume 1 (Part One) Ministry of Justice. - T .: «Vektor-Press», 2010. - 816 p. - (Professional (qualified) reviews.

Oqyulov О. The Civil Code is the legal basis of our daily lives. Criteria of fairness. Scientific-practical, legal journal. №5th issue, 2020.

A.A. Gromov, A.V. Egorov Practical commentary on the first and second blocks of amendments to the Civil Code of the Russian Federation: the most significant amendments. M., 2014.S. 67.Cit. Quoted from: Tololaeva, N.V. The ratio of some grounds for the invalidity of the transaction / N.V. Tololaeva // Reference legal system "Consultant Plus". - Access mode:

Laptev A.N. On the issue of the application of a public order clause in the recognition and enforcement of foreign decisions in the Federal Republic of Germany // Moscow Journal of International Law. 2003. No. 4. P.125.

Italian Civil Code 1942. //

Lomako A.Yu. Invalid transaction and transaction: some aspects of the formation of concepts and their modern understanding // Civil law. - 2013. - No. 6. - P. 15.

Rustambekov I.R. Regulation of civil-legal relations on the Internet: Dis… yu.f.d. - T., 2017.

Illarionova T.I. Mechanism of action of civil law protective measures : Textbook. Sverdlovsk, USU. 1980. 76 p.

Slesarev V.L. Economic sanctions in Soviet Civil Law. - Krasnoyarsk: Publishing house of Krasnoyar. un-ta. 1989. 189 p.

Kheifets FS Invalidity of transactions in the Soviet civil law: dis. ... Cand. jurid. sciences. M., 1972.

Russian civil law: textbook: in 2 volumes / otv. ed. E.A. Sukhanov. M .: Statut, 2013.Vol. I: General part. Real right. Inheritance law. Intellectual rights. Personal non-property rights (chapter author - V.S.Em). P. 365.

Civil law: Textbook. Volume 1 / Ed. HE. Sadikova. - M .: KONTRAKT, INFRA-M, 2006 (chapter by O.V. Gutnikov).

Tololaeva N.V. The ratio of some grounds for the invalidity of the transaction / N.V. Tololaeva // Judge. - 2015. - No. 10.

Khalfina R.O. Treaty in English Civil Law. - M., 1959 .- 319 p.

French Civil Code / per. with fr. A.A. Zhukova, G.A. Pashkovskaya. - SPb., 2004 .- 1101 p.

Civil Code of Germany. Introductory law to the Civil Code. - M., 2004.- 816 p.

Golyshev V.G. Transactions in the credit sector and their invalidity: specialty: 12.00.08: abstract of thesis. ... Cand. legal entity Sciences / Golyshev Vadim Grigorievich.-M.,2003.-19 p.

Lavrinenko A.S. Legal consequences of invalidating a transaction // A.S. Lavrinenko, A.M. Vasiliev. - New Science: Problems and Prospects, 2016. - Issue. 3-1 (67). - P. 234–236.

Explanatory note “To the draft Federal Law“ On Amendments to Parts One, Two, Three and Four of the Civil Code of the Russian Federation, as well as to certain legislative acts of the Russian Federation ”// ATP Consultant Plus.

Shakhmatov V. P. The composition of illegal transactions and the consequences caused by them. Tomsk, 1967. pp. 214 - 216.

Egorov Yu.P. Invalidity of transactions that are illegal in terms of their content // Legality. - 2004. - No. 6. - S. 47-51. P. 50.

Blinova M.A. Invalidity of the transaction. Committed for a purpose contrary to the foundations of law and order and morality: Dis. Cand. legal entity sciences. - M., 2003. P. 118